Signals Sent

September 13, 2024

After hitting all-time highs in July, cracks began to appear during the month of August. The unofficial last summer month began with a ferocious sell-off, resulting in the S&P500 dropping 6% during the first three days alone and the Magnificent 7 falling almost 10% during the same period. It was the worst start to a month in over 20 years and was owed largely to growth concerns after the July payrolls report came in much lighter than expected. Other key pieces of data suggested that the economy is softening, and the Federal Reserve has kept interest rates too high for too long. Contagion in Japan related to its currency and interest rate contributed to the sour mood and elevated volatility, with the VIX spiking to its third-highest level ever seen. Not a fun start. 

Yet in just 11 trading days following that steep decline, the market fully recovered and ascended toward the record July peaks. This rally was based on stronger-than-expected economic data combined with the near-guarantee of interest rate cuts in the coming months. Throughout August, the Federal Reserve signaled that it would likely cut interest rates in September – with recession risks low and core inflation in line with expectations. During his highly anticipated speech in Jackson Hole, Fed Chair Powell confirmed that he was confidant in the directionality of inflation data and would shift the emphasis to supporting the labor market and therefore “adjusting” monetary policy. Essentially, he said that inflation has been tamed and it is time to start reducing market interest rates. Both stock and bond markets rallied aggressively as a result.

Chair Powell is not wrong. The US economy indeed remains modestly strong. While unemployment did tick up in July, it is still low by historical standards and when combined with decent GDP growth and moderating inflation, it does appear that the economy is primed for the coveted soft-landing scenario. The above economic data, combined with the widespread view that monetary policy is far too restrictive, suggest that the Federal Open Market Committee will reduce its benchmark rate by 0.25% in September, followed by a further 0.25-0.5% by year-end. Given the political elements involving the November election, it is unlikely that Chair Powell or the committee will deliver any surprises here. We believe the committee will stick to the script whilst simultaneously remaining data dependent. Rate cuts, here we come!

Looking forward, we are heading into a seasonally challenging time, with September being the most volatile month of the year historically. Over the last five years, the S&P500 has delivered a negative average return of -4.2% during month number nine. Perhaps this time is different with an interest rate cut due on the 18th. Certainly, the market is saying as much, with the odds of a September cut approaching 100% in betting markets. The question becomes: will it be a 0.25% or a 0.5% reduction? The possibility of a 50bps cut remains on the table if certain key economic reports, namely jobless claims and nonfarm payrolls, do not meet expectations. We also must contend with “triple witching” on the 20th (derivative expirations on options, index futures, etc.) as well as the November election, which has begun to loom large.

Given the above combined with a seasonally weak time period, we would not be surprised to see additional volatility in both stock and bond markets. That being said, we are positioned for whatever the market will throw at us, and we stand ready to react accordingly. As ever, we thank you for your ongoing trust and support.